America Has An Existential Civics Education Crisis That More ‘Civics Education’ Will Only Make Worse

As leftists push for greater control of what children learn about American history and how Americans define their civic responsibilities, a majority of Americans support more “civics education,” an interesting new Heritage Foundation survey finds.

“[T]wo-thirds of parents and nearly three-quarters of teachers share a strong desire to see greater emphasis on civics education. Indeed, interest in civics education among parents has increased substantially over the past five years. However, only around one-third of each group are satisfied with the type of content included in their schools’ civics education,” says the report, which Gabe Kaminsky exclusively reported here.

This datapoint might be taken by some Republicans and right-branded institutions to support an effort underway branded as a “bipartisan” push to “increase civics education.” Look, something about which most Americans can agree amid a time of bitter cultural divides!

The problem with this takeaway is that it is neither supported by the rest of the report, the context into which it is released, the history of American public education, nor the increasingly clarifying realities of America’s current cold civil war.

Stanley Kurtz and the National Association of Scholars have done yeoman’s work exposing the national “civics education” agitation as a leftist play for increased political power. In short, here’s the problem this report underscores about that political background: Most Americans may want more “civics.” But they do not at all agree what “civics” means.

‘Civics’ Means Two Completely Opposite Things

There are in fact two utterly incompatible major views of what Americans should learn and believe about their nation’s history and ideals. The first is the institutionally dominant view epitomized by critical race theory and CRT in action like The New York Times’s 1619 Project.

It is a twisted reading of the historical record to support a fundamentally anti-American stance opposed to individual natural rights and equality before the law. This version of “civics” teaches Americans to treat skin color (and sometimes other characteristics like sexual behavior) as determinative of one’s past, present, and future.

Some Americans want this. Some do not.

The opposing, and original, view of American civics aims to pass on the traditions, dispositions, habits, and beliefs that created the United States and have made it the best nation in world history. Notice I didn’t say “a perfect” nation, because it was never perfect and it still isn’t — not by a long shot. Everyone agrees the United States does many egregiously bad things.

But to be an American has historically meant a commitment to specific political principles and responsibilities, epitomized by those named in the Declaration of Independence, Constitution, and Bill of Rights. Without these beliefs and practices governing the majority of Americans, the United States as it was founded ceases to exist.

Unlike the critical theory and “action civics” crowd, those who want the founders’ civics to continue controlling our nation believe there was great good in the United States as founded — perhaps the greatest good united in any government ever. So losing its peerless preservation of citizens’ natural rights is to us is a tragedy to fend off for as long as humanly possible, and at great personal cost.

These two views are fundamentally incompatible. As Christopher Caldwell has ably shown, the “rival constitution” of identity politics is a direct competitor to the U.S. Constitution. They have lived in uneasy coexistence since the identity politics constitution was instituted largely in the 1960s under Lyndon B. Johnson. Today it is clear this mess of pottage may have largely supplanted the original American Constitution.

Americans Versus the Anti-Americans

How does all this affect civics education today? It takes “bipartisanship” and nationalized approaches off the table, because such unities are only possible among those who share a commitment to the United States’ fundamental political ideals, such as support for free speech, freedom to worship, the fundamental political equality of all without penalties for any skin color or sex, and the rule of law.

Democrat leaders and vanguards today simply do not share these fundamental American ideals. They openly repudiate and work to erase them. In that sense, they are Americans in name, but not at heart. Today’s leftists openly profess anti-American philosophy and actions, as the entire critical race insanity indicates. Therefore, bipartisan approaches are impossible for all but the most surface of pursuits.

How to effectively pass on the American identity to each successive generation is not a surface pursuit. Aside from national and individual security, it is the most important national pursuit of all. It is an existential pursuit that requires existential politics: We win, you lose. Because if we don’t win, the nation we love quickly stops existing.

Other parts of the Heritage report underscore this context. It finds “38.1 percent of parents and 31.5 percent of teachers are satisfied with the type of content included in their schools’ civics education,” and that their dissatisfaction is split. Many parents and even more teachers are dissatisfied with current civics instruction because it’s not leftist enough.

This surfaces throughout the survey findings. One reflection appears to be in the finding that more Democrats than Republicans think more “civic” education is needed. From other polls and social science showing what Democrats think of Republican voters — that we are essentially heartless ignoramuses — one can suspect why Democrats think more “civic education” is needed.

Here’s another example. The report oddly makes no mention of “action civics,” a term frequently used by the left for using publicly funded classrooms as recruiting centers for leftist activism. This is the version of “civics” the left is working to impose nationwide, to put the nail in the coffin enclosing their control of America’s future through its education institutions. The Heritage report surfaces clear hallmarks of “action civics” already taking effect, such as the shocking finding that 58 percent of parents support “high school students participating in advocacy efforts for social causes.”

The report finds other reflections that significant percentages of parents, and even greater percentages of teachers, support teaching leftist “civics” using public resources. Fifty-one percent of parents and 60 percent of teachers said “gender roles” are relevant to “civics” curriculum. By a large margin, teachers thought it was much more important to “expose students to varying viewpoints about America” than that civics classes “ensure we are a united America.”

One of the few bright spots in the report was its finding that approximately 6 in 10 of both teachers and parents believe the Founding era and Constitution are highly relevant to civics curricula. Yet again, it’s unclear what’s inside that agreement, as leftists have for more than a century claimed to support the Constitution, by which they mean the “living Constitution” that effectively means a nullified Constitution.

That particular bait and switch is breaking down, however, as increasingly those on the left feel freer to flip off the Constitution and propose amendments to disembowel it. Using words with different meanings than most people impute to them is a timeless trick of power mongers, and it’s been employed throughout this entire fight over whether Americans will live under the original Constitution or its bastardized enemy. The civics curriculum battle is key to who will win that ultimate war, and the left clearly has the upper hand.

Fifty percent of parents and 58 percent of teachers said critical race theory should be included in civics curricula, and one-third of parents and 4 in 10 teachers said CRT should be the focus of civics curricula (see graph below). Given that critical race theory equals institutionalized anti-white racism and anti-American animus, these numbers are alarming. Virtually zero Americans should support anti-American animus or racism of any kind, not one-third of Americans and even more teachers of our youngest generation.

Given all this, it’s no surprise that “Democrats are 15.6 percentage points more satisfied than Republicans” with civics curriculum in schools, and teachers consistently reflected much more leftist views than parents in the Heritage survey. More extreme teacher leftism is a consistent survey finding going back decades, and its reoccurrence in this survey on an existential issue should accent how deeply important it is for Republican officeholders to immediately address the teaching pipeline.

So “allowing alternative teacher certification” and banning CRT may be the best recommendations in the report. But we need a heck of a lot more. Republicans have been appointed watchmen against these kinds of threats by their voters for decades, only to sleep while anti-American barbarians have taken over the country.

It is completely unacceptable if Republicans don’t have their pants on fire over addressing this existential national crisis. I don’t want to live in a casino that political factions attempt to loot at the expense of everyone else. I want to live in the United States of America, which was founded to guarantee my God-given rights to self-defense, free speech, freedom of worship, freedom from government surveillance, and the people’s political sovereignty.

That may no longer be a possible future for the country I love. But I’ll be damned if I’m not going to do my utmost to make it more possible within my lifetime, and any person with any iota of political power had better join me in that patriotic pursuit or resign this minute for his cowardice.

That requires teaching Americans the many reasons to love and respect their own country, and exhibit gratitude for all she gives us. A nation that hates itself is not a nation for long.


Political prisoner Solange is free AGAIN after BEEN KIDNAPPED twice by self confessed terrorist criminal groups Click HERE for TRUE story


The Covid-19 Vaccine Kills!

What is going on is a bio weapon heart stopper - the elites call a 'vaccine'

Joe Biden Is Using Your Tax Dollars To Make American Kids Hate Their Country

Joe Biden Is Using Your Tax Dollars To Make American Kids Hate Their Country

The Biden administration cites the anti-American 1619 Project and hatemonger Ibram X. Kendi as guiding its criteria for federal American history and civics education grants in a proposed rule out in the Federal Register on April 19.

The U.S. Department of Education’s education priorities as described in the Register accepts and amplifies Chinese Communist propaganda accusing the United States of “systemic racism” and recommending anti-white racism as the cure. The document cites The New York Times’s error-riddled 1619 Project, divisive identity politics-driven materials from the Smithsonian Institution, and Kendi’s racist form of “antiracism” as examples for the kind of preschool through college indoctrination of children the Biden administration will use taxpayer funds and federal power to promote.

The administration approvingly notes in its proposed regulations:

…schools across the country are working to incorporate anti-racist practices into teaching and learning. As the scholar Ibram X. Kendi has expressed, ‘[a]n antiracist idea is any idea that suggests the racial groups are equals in all their apparent differences—that there is nothing right or wrong with any racial group. Antiracist ideas argue that racist policies are the cause of racial inequities.’ It is critical that the teaching of American history and civics creates learning experiences that validate and reflect the diversity, identities, histories, contributions, and experiences of all students.

In turn, racially, ethnically, culturally, and linguistically responsive teaching and learning practices contribute to what has been called an ‘identity-safe’ learning environment.

The proposed regulations also declare the administration’s plan to use public resources to prevent American children from believing what it calls “misinformation,” declaring that false beliefs are a danger to “democracy.”

“Effective civics education is vital to protecting the Nation’s democracy—especially at a time when its core institutions and values are threatened by misinformation,” the administration’s proposal states. It therefore declares the administration’s intention to also fund “civics education” programs to increase “news literacy” and “distinguish fact from misinformation.”

This set of regulations is yet more evidence that the Biden administration intends to use every lever of power it can to serve the interests of America’s enemies, including federal power over public education. The Biden administration’s foreign policy not only echoes but amplifies false anti-American talking points deliberately deployed by the Chinese Communist Party to destabilize and ultimately destroy their top foreign competitor.

United Nations Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield recently doubled down on her claim to the world that the United States’s alleged “systemic racism” is a reason for Americans to consider our society as equal in shame and worthiness to countries that with no shame currently keep millions of people in concentration camps where women are raped by guards.

The Chinese Communists use false claims like these to undermine Americans’ will and to set Americans at each others’ throats to distract us from soberly and prudently acting to deny the evil Chinese regime the opportunity to displace us as the world’s strongest country. Democrats haven’t stated the real reasons they also want America’s young to hate their ancestors, freedoms, rights, privileges, and way of life, and to train Americans to judge each other according to the color of our skin. But in this rule and numerous other actions from today’s left, such as the critical race theory struggle sessions they are spreading to schools everywhere, it’s clear Democrats mean to make that happen.

Sometimes, Republicans help them. As Stanley Kurtz notes, many Republicans have signaled openness to expanding rather than ending the federal role in controlling what schools teach. They have actively assisted in the cartelization of U.S. education that increases its ideological corruption. Instead, given rules like this and other steps Democrats have taken across the land to amplify and entrench critical race theory at every level of American society, Republicans need to wise up and realize that when they expand federal power, this is how Democrats will use it.

“We needn’t wait to see how the Biden administration will implement federal efforts to support American history and civics. This new rule tells us all we need to know,” Kurtz says. “We are set for a huge showdown over federal efforts to press leftist action civics and Critical Race Theory on the states. ”

Republicans at all levels need to begin a systematic campaign to end the federal government’s ability to supercharge leftist institutional racism, and to release American schools from the interlocking monopolies that assist this deep politicization. For those who somehow remain clueless in 2021, let me remind them that Kendi is the guy who openly advocates for a constitutional amendment to overturn the rest of the Constitution by implementing actual nationwide systemic racism.

As Benjamin Weingarten recently pointed out, Kendi is a guy who says “white terror is as American as” the American flag, “to truly be antiracist, you also have to truly be anti-capitalist,” and openly demands instituting Jim Crow against white people:

The only remedy to racist discrimination is antiracist discrimination. The only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination. The only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination.

Instead of opposing a guy calling for a national system of laws discriminating against Americans based solely on their race, the Biden administration is citing his ideas as their inspiration for their plans for U.S. public schools! These are people who need to have power taken away from them immediately, not given more money and programs to use on behalf of leftist racism. Anyone with power who doesn’t wage political war on anything people like this control or influence is a fool complicit in hastening America’s demise.


Political prisoner Solange is free AGAIN after BEEN KIDNAPPED twice by self confessed terrorist criminal groups Click HERE for TRUE story


The Covid-19 Vaccine Kills!

What is going on is a bio weapon heart stopper - the elites call a 'vaccine'


Please help truthPeep spread the word :)